TopNotch Agency
You Are Reading
Midjourney Copyright 2025: Protect Your AI Art or Risk Losing It
0
AI, Blog

Midjourney Copyright 2025: Protect Your AI Art or Risk Losing It

Midjourney Copyright 2025: Protect Your AI Art or Risk Losing It

Midjourney Copyright Guide 2025: Legal Risks & How to Protect Your AI Art

Flowchart explaining Midjourney copyright status, commercial license tiers, and legal risks for AI-generated art
Flowchart explaining Midjourney copyright status, commercial license tiers, and legal risks for AI-generated art
Understanding the intersection of Midjourney’s license and U.S. copyright law is essential for protecting your AI-generated work.
For digital artists, content marketers, and entrepreneurs, Midjourney has unlocked a new frontier of visual creativity. However, the critical question of copyright for Midjourney-generated images remains a complex legal puzzle. This in-depth guide cuts through the confusion, providing a clear, authoritative breakdown of ownership rights, U.S. Copyright Office policies, and practical strategies for commercial use. Understanding these nuances is not optional—it’s fundamental to protecting your work and your business in the age of AI art.

Key Takeaways: Navigating Midjourney Image Copyright

  • License vs. Copyright: Your Midjourney subscription grants a license to use images, but this is distinct from holding an enforceable copyright, which the U.S. Copyright Office currently denies to purely AI-generated works.
  • Commercial Use is Governed by Tier: Paid plans allow commercial use, but enterprises over $1M in revenue require a Pro or Mega plan. Free users are restricted to non-commercial Creative Commons licenses.
  • High Risk for Core Branding: Using AI-generated images for logos or primary brand assets carries significant risk of brand dilution due to the lack of exclusive copyright protection.
  • The Human-AI Hybrid Path: The most defensible strategy involves substantial human modification to the AI output, creating a hybrid work with a stronger claim to copyright protection.

1. Demystifying Ownership: What Your Midjourney License Actually Grants

Your rights are defined not by traditional copyright law first, but by Midjourney’s Terms of Service. It’s vital to separate the concept of asset ownership from specific licensing rights.

  • Paid Subscribers (Standard, Pro, Mega Plans): You receive a broad Asset License. This permits selling, merchandising, and business use (e.g., marketing, product design) provided your company’s annual revenue is under $1 million USD. Enterprises exceeding this must use a Pro or Mega plan for compliant commercial use.
  • Free Trial Users: Your rights are limited to a Creative Commons Noncommercial 4.0 Attribution International License (CC BY-NC 4.0). You can share and adapt images, but not for commercial purposes, and you must credit Midjourney.
  • The Critical “Ownership” Caveat: While Midjourney states you “own” the assets you create, this is effectively a license to use. The exclusive rights inherent to copyright, like legally preventing others from copying or selling your image, are severely limited, as explained by the U.S. Copyright Office.

Strategic Insight: Your license is your first line of defense. Choose the correct tier for your commercial goals. For a detailed comparison, see our guide to Midjourney Pricing Plans to select the right subscription.

This is the most significant legal hurdle for Midjourney copyright protection. The U.S. Copyright Office has been unequivocal: copyright requires human authorship.

  • The Official Stance: In its March 2023 guidance and subsequent rulings (like the “Zarya of the Dawn” decision), the Office states that works generated solely by AI, like a basic Midjourney prompt result, lack the necessary human creative control for copyright registration.
  • Practical Implication: You can publish your Midjourney image, but you likely cannot stop others from using, selling, or remixing it. It exists in a “public domain-like” state regarding exclusive federal copyright.
  • The “Human-AI Collaboration” Loophole: There is a critical path forward. The Office indicates that works featuring substantial human creative contribution—where the AI output is significantly modified, curated, or integrated into a larger human-authored work—may be eligible for protection in the human-authored aspects. This hybrid approach is key for artists seeking protection.

Midjourney’s operational model introduces unique vulnerabilities for your generated images.

  • Default Public Gallery: Images created on standard plans are public on the Midjourney community gallery. While “Stealth Mode” on Pro/Mega plans offers privacy, your prompts and the fundamental image data contribute to the system’s learning.
  • Non-Deletable Training Data: Per their Terms, Midjourney retains an irrevocable right to use your prompts, images, and data to train its AI models. You cannot “delete” your creative contribution from their dataset, reinforcing the non-exclusive nature of your work.

Using Midjourney images for business isn’t illegal, but it’s a calculated risk requiring management.

  • Brand Dilution & Non-Exclusivity: The lack of copyright means a competitor could legally use an identical or strikingly similar AI-generated image, causing customer confusion and diluting your brand’s unique identity. This makes Midjourney images a poor choice for primary logos.
  • Direct Infringement Liability: Midjourney’s Terms hold you responsible. If you knowingly generate images that infringe on existing copyrights or trademarks (e.g., generating a character owned by Disney), you are liable. Midjourney may also take action against you to protect itself.
  • Evolving Case Law: Ongoing lawsuits against AI companies (like Getty Images v. Stability AI) regarding training data could force changes to licensing terms and user rights in the future.

 

💡 Strategic Insight: Don’t navigate AI marketing risks alone. Develop a robust strategy with our guide to Using Perplexity AI for Marketing.

The Safe Path for Commercial Midjourney Use

Use this flowchart to guide your risk assessment and workflow.

Start: You have a Midjourney image for commercial use.

Is it for a logo, brand mascot, or unique product design?
↓ Yes → HIGH RISK. Strongly advise against it. Use original human-made art.
↓ No →
Will you significantly modify it with human creative input?
↓ No → MEDIUM RISK. Acceptable for blog/social media, but no exclusivity.
↓ Yes →
Document your modification process thoroughly.

LOWER RISK / DEFENSIBLE WORK. Hybrid creation with a stronger claim to copyright protection.

This simplified guide is based on U.S. Copyright Office policy and best-practice legal advice.

The international legal landscape varies dramatically, making a one-size-fits-all approach dangerous.

Jurisdiction Key Law / Stance Protection for AI Work? Practical Implication
United States Copyright Act, USPTO & Copyright Office Guidance No (for purely AI-generated works) No federal copyright registration. Protection is possible only for human-authored elements.
United Kingdom Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, Section 9(3) Yes (for “computer-generated” works) Copyright granted for 50 years from creation. The “author” is the person making the necessary arrangements.
European Union Various national laws; EU Directives Uncertain / Leaning No Generally requires “author’s own intellectual creation” by a human. Strong human input is necessary.
Japan Copyright Act; 2018 MEXT Report Limited May protect works where AI is a tool, but not works “created by AI.” Human creative control is central.

Takeaway: If your business operates internationally, a single legal assumption is dangerous. Always seek country-specific legal advice for major projects.

6. Actionable Best Practices for Safe Midjourney Use

Protect yourself with a proactive, informed strategy:

  1. Conduct a Use-Case Audit: Categorize your intent.
    • Lower Risk: Social media visuals, blog post illustrations, internal mood boards.
    • Higher Risk: Logos, product designs, book covers, branded merchandise, unique characters.
  2. Adopt a Human-Centric Workflow: This is the single most important practice. Use the Midjourney output as a raw material. Significantly modify it in Photoshop, Affinity Designer, or Procreate—alter compositions, add original hand-drawn elements, and combine multiple generations. Meticulously document this creative process; it’s evidence of human authorship.
  3. Leverage Contract Law: If commissioning work from an artist using Midjourney, your contract with the artist should clearly assign all rights in the final, modified work to you, addressing the AI-generated component’s weaknesses.
  4. Conduct Trademark Searches: Before adopting any AI-generated image as a brand symbol, conduct a thorough trademark search. An image may be uncopyrightable but could still infringe on an existing registered trademark.
  5. Stay Relentlessly Informed: Follow updates from the U.S. Copyright Office, court rulings, and changes to Midjourney’s own Terms of Service. This field changes quarterly.

Strategic Insight: Justifying your AI tool investment is key. Measure success with our Perplexity AI Marketing ROI Guide.

Can I copyright a Midjourney image?

In the United States, no. The U.S. Copyright Office will not register a work produced solely by an AI like Midjourney. Copyright protection is reserved for works of human authorship.

Can I sell Midjourney images?

If you are a paid subscriber on a plan that matches your revenue level (under $1M/year for Standard), yes, Midjourney’s license permits it. However, remember you cannot stop others from selling the same or a very similar image, as you hold no exclusive copyright.

Is Midjourney art public domain?

Functionally, in the U.S., it behaves similarly to public domain material regarding copyright enforcement. However, your license terms from Midjourney still impose rules (like attribution for free users), and you must respect third-party copyrights in your prompts.

What is the safest way to use Midjourney commercially?

Use it for lower-risk applications like social media content. For higher-stakes projects, heavily modify the output with human creativity to create a hybrid work, document your process, and consider trademark protection for brand elements.

Conclusion: Empower Your Creativity with Knowledge

Navigating copyright for Midjourney-generated images is less about claiming traditional ownership and more about intelligent risk management and strategic workflow design. You have a powerful license to create and use AI art, but the absence of exclusive copyright is a fundamental legal reality.
The path forward is clear: match your subscription to your commercial needs, integrate profound human creativity into your AI-assisted process, and anchor your protection in contracts and trademarks where copyright falls short. By doing so, you can confidently harness Midjourney’s potential while safeguarding your artistic and commercial investments.

Next Step: Ready to scale your AI-powered projects? Master the art of research and execution with our advanced guide on Dominating Events with Perplexity AI.


Sources & Legal References

This guide is based on the following primary legal documents, official policies, and court rulings to ensure the highest accuracy and reliability.

  1. Midjourney. “Terms of Service.” https://docs.midjourney.com/docs/terms-of-service
  2. U.S. Copyright Office. “Copyright Registration Guidance: Works Containing Material Generated by Artificial Intelligence.” (March 2023). https://www.copyright.gov/ai/ai_policy_guidance.pdf
  3. U.S. Copyright Office. “Decision Letter on ‘Zarya of the Dawn’ Registration.” (February 2022). https://www.copyright.gov/docs/zarya-of-the-dawn.pdf
  4. Thaler v. Perlmutter, Civil Action No. 22-1564 (BAH) (D.D.C. Aug. 18, 2023). https://casetext.com/case/thaler-v-perlmutter-1
  5. UK Government. “Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.” Section 9(3). https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1988/48/section/9

About the Author & TopNotch Agency

This guide was meticulously researched and compiled by the Legal & Technology Research Team at TopNotch Agency. Our team includes specialists who track intellectual property law, AI policy, and digital content creation, providing actionable advice to artists, marketers, and businesses navigating the new digital landscape. We combine analysis of primary legal sources with practical industry experience to create authoritative, trustworthy resources.

TopNotch Agency is a digital strategy firm that helps clients leverage emerging technologies—from AI-generated art to advanced marketing analytics—safely and effectively. Our insights are grounded in real-world applications and a deep understanding of the legal frameworks that govern digital innovation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *